UK Debt Crisis Reoccurs

Advertisements

Do you recall the pension crisis in the UK? It's a memory that remains vivid for many, especially in the wake of recent market shifts that seem to echo those turbulent times.

This week, benchmark UK government bond prices soared by 20 basis points, reaching their highest level since 2008. Observers are cautiously recalling the disastrous mini-budget introduced by former Prime Minister Liz Truss in September 2022, which had previously pushed UK pensions to the brink of disaster.

Recent data shows that implied volatility for the pound has surged to 10%, marking the highest levels since the banking crisis in March 2023.

Adding to the unpredictability, analysts note that the recent sell-off does not seem to have a clear catalyst

Some suggest it is tied to increasing concerns regarding the UK’s fiscal outlookMeanwhile, with inflation accelerating, the Eurozone is poised to see an uptick in bond supply, pushing German bond yields to a five-month high.

What impacts can we expect from this wave of UK bond selling?

Under Currents

On Wednesday, UK government bond prices fell steeply for the second consecutive day, with the 10-year bond yield hitting its highest level since August 2008, while the 30-year bond yield has hit a 26-year high

The pound also plummeted, dropping over 1.2% against the dollar to a low of 1.2322, a figure not seen since April.

The yield on the 30-year UK government bond jumped over 13 basis points to 5.383%, the highest since August 1998. Furthermore, the benchmark 10-year bond yield surged to 4.821%, reflecting a significant uptick of 12 basis points—its largest single-day increase in nine monthsTwo-year bond yields also rose to their highest since February 2024 at 4.576%.

Simultaneously, yields on 30-year German and US government bonds have also reached their highest levels since July 2024 and November 2023, respectively.

What Are the Implications?

The financial markets now predict that the Bank of England will only cut interest rates twice this year, reducing the bank rate from 4.75% to 4.25%. This is in stark contrast to a Reuters survey last month, where economists anticipated four cuts.

Michiel Tukker, a senior European rates strategist at ING, commented, "While we believe structurally rates should be lower, changing direction may take time

Ongoing inflation, government spending, rising US rates, and supply pressures will continue to exert upward pressure on UK ratesThe pound has begun to face selling pressure, but further weakness should be limited—because this is not a sovereign crisis."

In the aftermath of Liz Truss’s "mini-budget" in September 2022, the damages to both the pound and UK government bond prices were much more severe, resulting in a pension crisis.

If high bond yields continue, Chancellor Rachel Reeves will face her own challengesThe UK's fiscal watchdog is set to update its forecasts on March 26; current projections suggest it is increasingly likely she will surpass her medium-term borrowing targets.

Sanjay Raja, chief UK economist at Deutsche Bank, estimates that if the recent rise in UK government bond yields continues, the annual interest payments on the UK debt could rise by approximately £10 billion ($12 billion) compared to forecasts made by the Office for Budget Responsibility on October 30 last year.

"What does this mean for fiscal outlook? Spending cuts, increased borrowing, and possibly tax hikes to cover emerging fiscal gaps," he elaborated, "The upcoming spring statement, spending review, and autumn budget could become a painful sequel to the Chancellor's historic inauguration budget."

Is a Crisis Repeating?

A survey released by the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) on Thursday indicates that optimism around the business prospects of UK financial companies for the fourth quarter of 2024 is declining at its fastest rate in two years

alefox

Although business volumes have increased over the past three months, the CBI's confidence index for financial companies fell to -28 in December, the largest drop since September 2022.

CBI highlighted that comments provided in the survey reflected concerns over the costs associated with Chancellor Rachel Reeves's budgetTo boost revenue, the government announced a 1.2 percentage point increase in employer national insurance contributions and lowered the contribution threshold for employersReeves stated that the rise in employer national insurance was necessary to fund public service investmentsThe CBI survey also showed a decline in the number of employees in financial companies over the past three months.

Should the current market conditions worsen, the Labour Party may have no choice but to cut spending and increase taxes to assure the market that "debt is being well managed." Budget concerns have been brewing for a long time, as successive Conservative Chancellors have failed to address the escalating debt burden which has reached its highest level since the early 1960s.

Analysts suggest that the latest bond storm is easily reminiscent of the mini-budget disaster under Liz Truss, yet comparisons to the debt crisis of the 1970s may be more apt.

Former Bank of England rate setter Martin Weale asserted that if market sentiments do not shift, a Labour government may need to adopt austerity measures to reassure the market that the ever-growing debt burden is being addressed.

Weale noted the similarities to the "nightmare" of the 1976 debt crisis when the government was forced to seek assistance from the International Monetary Fund